Santa Cruz City Council · Tuesday, November 17, 2026, 12:00 PM · Item 23 · Public Hearings

MajorHousing, Planning & development

19 townhouses proposed at 528 Frederick Street

In plain English

The City Council is asked to approve a project at 528 Frederick Street that would build 19 townhouses in four attached buildings on what is now a surface parking lot. The approval package includes a subdivision map, coastal permit, design permit, fence permit, permission to remove five heritage-sized trees, and density bonus waivers from city rules on building height, front setback and spacing between buildings. The project started as 23 units and 11 heritage tree removals; the owner, 440 Frederick LLC, redesigned it to 19 units and transferred the sensitive creek-side area back to the adjacent Santa Cruz Bible Church property. A yes vote approves the project with the conditions of approval recommended by the Planning Commission, which voted 5-0-1 in support on November 5, 2026.

Neighbors on Frederick Street, especially property owners directly north of proposed units 17-19, would live next to new two- and three-story townhouses built up to 31 feet 11 inches tall and would lose five heritage-sized trees; buyers would gain 19 ownership homes, four of them priced as affordable units.

Key facts

  • 19 townhouses in four attached buildings: 13 two-story and six three-story units, with two garage parking spaces per unit, 19 Class 1 and 6 Class 2 bike spaces.
  • Four affordable units; two are both density bonus and inclusionary units sold to households at 80% of area median income with prices set using 70% AMI, converting after 55 years to inclusionary units priced using 80-120% AMI to stay affordable in perpetuity.
  • Five heritage-sized trees would be removed (down from 11 originally): three Coast Live Oaks in or within 5 feet of building foundations and two Callery Pears in the drainage system footprint. Replacement is required at a 2:1 ratio in the Coastal Zone.
  • Requested waivers: height from 30 feet to 31 feet 11 inches, front setback reduced to 3 feet 5 inches from 15 feet, and spacing between townhouse groups reduced from 13 feet 6 inches to 12 feet.
  • A recorded lot line adjustment moved 19,430 square feet of biotic area to the church parcel (APN 011-081-72), shrinking the site from 78,408 to 58,806 square feet; the receiving owner agreed to a voluntary open space deed restriction.

Reasons to support

  • The applicant redesigned the project to avoid Hagemann Gulch Reach 2, the riparian corridor and setbacks entirely, cutting units from 23 to 19 and square footage from 77,453 to 55,357, and cutting heritage tree removals from 11 to five.
  • The 19 units equal 14.1 dwelling units per acre, within the 14-to-27 unit range allowed by the Low-Medium Residential General Plan designation, and build homes on an underused parking lot near transit, shops and services.
  • Staff say State Density Bonus Law requires granting waivers that would otherwise physically preclude the project as designed, the city bears the legal burden to justify denial, and none of the legal grounds for denial (state or federal law conflict, historic resource impact, or a measurable health and safety impact) apply here.

Reasons to oppose or change it

  • Neighbors at the September 22, 2025 community meeting and the Planning Commission hearing raised traffic and parking impacts, building height, privacy and shading on properties to the north, loss of heritage trees, and disruptive construction; some asked that the item be continued until issues are resolved.
  • Because the site sits about 2 feet above the property to the north and sloped-site construction puts unit 19 roughly five feet above the neighbor's grade, staff acknowledge the perceived height is greater than the measured height, even though the measured height meets the 30-foot standard.
  • Residents asked that units 17-19 be shifted south away from the north property line; the applicant says that 5-foot strip is needed for utilities and fire access, so the units stay 7 feet from the interior side line and five heritage trees still come down because townhouses on small individual lots cannot be redesigned around them.

Make your voice heard

Pick a side and we'll draft a short email to citycouncil@santacruzca.gov that you can edit and send from your own account. Emails to the body become part of the public record.

How to take part

Show up: Tuesday, November 17, 2026 at 12:00 PM, Council Chambers, 809 Center Street, Santa Cruz. California's open-meetings law (the Brown Act) gives you the right to speak on agenda items. Remote-participation links, when offered, are on the agenda.

Write in: citycouncil@santacruzca.gov (from City of Santa Cruz City Council page (santacruzca.gov/Government/City-Council), checked 2026-09-22)

Deadline: Recent City Council agendas set the deadline for correspondence to be included in the agenda packet at 5:00 p.m. the day before the meeting.

Email sent to the Council is public record.

Official wording

528 Frederick Street: CP25-0075 (APN 011-081-71) Consideration of an Application and Associated Actions to Construct 19 Townhouses on Property Located in the R-L/CZ-O (Multiple Residence - Low-Density District/Coastal Zone Overlay) Zone Districts. Environmental Review: Categorical Exemption 15332, In-Fill Development Projects. Owner: 440 Frederick LLC. (CD) LOCATION: District 2 Motion to adopt a resolution acknowledging the environmental determination (Categorical Exemption Section 15332, Class 32) and approval of the Tentative Subdivision Map, Coastal Permit, Design Permit, Conditional Fence Permit, Heritage Tree Removal Permit, and Density Bonus request, based on the findings listed in the draft resolution and the Conditions of Approval attached as Exhibit “A.”

Summary written by claude-opus-5 from the agenda and the Staff report (agenda packet, pages 417-446). It can contain mistakes. The official documents govern.