Santa Cruz City Council · Tuesday, November 17, 2026, 12:00 PM · Item 24 · Public Hearings
Five years of water rate increases and new drought surcharges up for adoption
In plain English
The City Council would hold the required public hearing and then adopt a new water rate structure with increases every January 1 from 2027 through 2031 for all Santa Cruz Municipal Utilities customers. Fixed monthly "ready-to-serve" charges based on meter size would rise sharply (a 5/8-inch meter goes from $19.13 to $32.27 on January 1, 2027, reaching $48.10 by 2031), so that fixed charges cover about 20% of costs instead of about 10%. The separate Quantity Charge, Infrastructure Reinvestment Fee and Rate Stabilization Fee would be merged into one per-unit water rate, landscape irrigation would drop from three tiers to two, and flat monthly drought fees would be replaced with drought surcharges of 10% to 94% of the water rate that apply only when the Council declares a water shortage. A yes vote also finds that the City's written responses adequately answer the legal objections filed against the rates.
Every household and business served by the city water system, inside the city and in areas like Live Oak, would pay more each month — a single-family home using 5 CCF would go from $99.48 to $112.07 — to fund $287 million in planned water projects over five years.
Key facts
- New rates take effect January 1, 2027 and run through December 31, 2031, with increases on January 1 of 2027, 2028, 2029, 2030 and 2031.
- The Department projects collecting about $387 million in rate revenue from FY 2027 through FY 2031, funding an estimated $287 million in capital improvements, including $222,830,000 for rehabilitation of the Graham Hill Water Treatment Plant.
- Fixed monthly charges jump most for large meters: a 2-inch meter goes from $25.56 to $202.85 on January 1, 2027, and $302.32 by 2031. Tier 1 residential water drops slightly from $16.07 to $15.96 per CCF in 2027, then rises to $23.79 by 2031.
- As of October 26, 2026, the City had received 39 valid written protests and 14 timely legal objections under Assembly Bill 2257. If written protests come from a majority of affected properties, the increases cannot be adopted; the City Clerk tallies protests through the close of the hearing.
- Drought surcharges would be a percentage added to the regular water rate: 10% at Stage 1, 23% at Stage 2, 40% at Stage 3, 63% at Stage 4 and 94% at Stage 5, ending automatically when the Council's shortage declaration ends.
Reasons to support
- Much of the system that collects, treats, stores and delivers water is aging, and rates fund $287 million of replacement and reliability work over five years, including the Graham Hill Water Treatment Plant.
- Costs like water production, maintenance and debt payments stay largely the same no matter how much water is sold, so recovering about 20% of revenue through fixed charges — still below the 30-45% industry benchmark — steadies finances when use drops.
- Affordability measures continue: tiered rates keep the lowest tier for essential indoor use, and the Utility Customer Assistance Program gives $63 per month inside the City and $25 outside, plus $756 per year for eligible multi-unit households inside the City ($300 outside), funded by penalties and late fees rather than rates.
Reasons to oppose or change it
- Written objections filed with the City argue that projected revenues exceed costs, that costs are allocated disproportionately among customer classes, and that the rates are designed arbitrarily; the Council is being asked to find those objections adequately answered without further review or reduction.
- Shifting more revenue to fixed meter charges means customers who conserve save less on their bill, since a larger share of the bill no longer responds to how much water they use.
- The fixed-charge increases fall hardest on accounts with large meters — apartment buildings, businesses and institutions — where a 4-inch meter goes from $63.15 to $796.46 per month in 2027, a cost that applies whether or not water use changes.
Make your voice heard
Pick a side and we'll draft a short email to citycouncil@santacruzca.gov that you can edit and send from your own account. Emails to the body become part of the public record.
How to take part
Show up: Tuesday, November 17, 2026 at 12:00 PM, Council Chambers, 809 Center Street, Santa Cruz. California's open-meetings law (the Brown Act) gives you the right to speak on agenda items. Remote-participation links, when offered, are on the agenda.
Write in: citycouncil@santacruzca.gov (from City of Santa Cruz City Council page (santacruzca.gov/Government/City-Council), checked 2026-09-22)
Deadline: Recent City Council agendas set the deadline for correspondence to be included in the agenda packet at 5:00 p.m. the day before the meeting.
Email sent to the Council is public record.
Official wording
Conduct a Public Hearing Required to Adopt a Resolution Establishing an Updated Water Rate Structure, Adjusting Fixed-Cost Ready-to-Serve Charges, and Water Usage Based Consumption Charges for Implementation over Five Consecutive Years Beginning On January 1, 2027, and Establishing Drought Cost Recovery Fees to be Implemented in Response to a Council Declared Water Shortage Emergency (WT) LOCATION: Citywide Motion to: 1) Determine that the City's written responses adequately address the objections submitted pursuant to Government Code section 53759.1, that no clarification, reduction, or further review of the proposed water rates is warranted; 2) Accept the 2026 Water Rate Study including the Cost-of-Service analysis prepared by Bartle Wells Associates, which provides the basis for the proposed water rates and rate structure for the five-year period January 1, 2027, through December 31, 2031; and 3) Adopt a resolution establishing an updated water rate structure, and a five-year schedule of water rates, fees and charges including adjusting fixed-cost (or ready-to-serve charges), and water usage based consumption charges for implementation on January 1, 2027, January 1, 2028, January 1, 2029, January 1, 2030, and January 1, 2031; establishing drought surcharges to be implemented in response to a City Council-declared water shortage emergency, and rescinding Resolution No. NS-29,897 upon the effective date of the new rates.
Summary written by claude-opus-5 from the agenda and the Staff report (agenda packet, pages 587-616). It can contain mistakes. The official documents govern.